Turning To AI For Money Advice Has Risks: What To Know
The benefits and risks of using AI for financial advice
Here’s what to expect in this newsletter!
(P.S. If this newsletter is cut off in your email just visit our Substack!)
📰 Interesting financial news: Stay up to date on what’s happening in the economy.
📝 This week’s main topic: What this newsletter’s title is about!
📰 Interesting financial news
Student loan borrowers won’t see wage garnishments, for now. (USA Today)
Underwater car trade-ins are on the rise, and drivers owe a record amount. (CNBC)
US banking giants reap bigger profits as borrowers seek more loans.(Reuter)
📈 What’s popping in the stock market
What emotion is driving the stock market today? Check out CNN’s fear and greed index.
2 to 3 other topics
📝 Main topic: The reliance on AI
Raise your hand if you’ve ever asked ChatGPT for dinner ideas!
Whether it’s recipes or meals, AI tools make many areas of life easier. Generative AI can help you organize data and answer those pesky questions that pop into your head at 2 a.m.
These systems, which mimic human interactions, have become companions in our daily lives and even handle our financial needs.
According to a report by Intuit Credit Karma, 66% of Americans who use popular AI tools have turned to them for financial advice. Gen Z and millennials rely on chatbots the most, with 82% using them for budgeting, investing, and tax planning.
I’ve used ChatGPT countless times to double-checks simple math while working on my budget. However, we shouldn’t rely too heavily on these tools when managing our finances.
Why? Because money isn’t just numbers. Emotions, past experiences, and current situations shape how we earn and spend. So, simply plugging in a bunch of numbers to AI doesn’t give us a full or accurate picture of our financial reality.
We’re not saying to ditch AI altogether, but it’s important to understand both the limitations and benefits of using it for your finances.
With that said, let’s go over a few key points.
Redefine what’s possible for you!
Turn your ambitions into actions!
Click here or the image above to pre-order your copy!
What AI can be useful for
AI can be surprisingly helpful with money management. Here are some ways it shines:
Basic definitions
ChatGPT, Gemini, or Claude are great at breaking down complex financial terms. Ever felt lost when someone starts talking about a Roth IRA? Or had to just nod and smile during a chat about diversifying a portfolio?
Thankfully, you don’t need an economics degree to understand finances. AI can clearly define basic terms so you can better understand both the financial world and your own money.
Budgeting, planning, and savings temp0lates
One of my favorite features of ChatGPT is its ability to create templates. I’m an idea person, which means organizing my thoughts on paper, or better yet, in an Excel spreadsheetc, an feel impossible.
Fortunately, I can type my ideas into a chatbot and voilà, everything is neatly organized.
AI can also create financial checklists, help you calculate weekly savings goals, and support other aspects of financial planning.
Educational content and general financial literacy
If you want to learn more about budgeting, compound interest, or different types of savings accounts, AI has your back. It’s great at explaining and summarizing information across a wide range of financial topics.
Think of AI as a helpful assistant, someone to handle the busy work you’d rather avoid.
But here’s the key: AI doesn’t know you personally. Even if you use it daily and it tells you how clever you are, it only has a service level understanding of who you are.
AI can recognize patterns and gather information, but at the end of the day, it isn’t real. It can sympathize with your financial challenges, but it doesn’t truly understand eating rice five nights in a row because most of your income went toward rent and bills.
Let’s take a deeper look at the limitations of these knowledgeable machines so you can use AI more wisely for your finances.
What AI can’t do well
Not too long ago, I was looking to make some extra cash and asked ChatGPT to help me earn an extra $500. It broke everything down step by step and even ended with a cheerful “You got this, girl!”
While the advice was thorough, it wasn’t practical. AI had made assumptions about my time, skills, and available resources based on previous prompts. And even though ChatGPT might “know” a lot about me, it doesn’t understand my history, behavior patterns, or emotional triggers.
The advice looked sound, but it was difficult to put into practice.
Chatbots can offer general advice they’ve gathered from financial articles (often times without attribution or credit) to help you pay off debt, or start investing. The problem is, that advice doesn’t take into account your personal beliefs, habits, or financial circumstances.
Unlike a human professional who considers all aspects of your life, AI tends to tell you what you want to hear. Even if you ask it to be honest or straightforward, it often gives the answer it thinks you want, not necessarily the one you need.
Financial advice influenced by culture, values, or financial trauma is something AI simply isn’t equipped to handle.
Always remember, your financial situation is uniquely yours, and AI can easily miss the nuances that truly matter.
The risk of oversimplified or incorrect advice
When you first started using AI, you probably noticed that little disclaimer reminding you to double-check your answers because AI can make mistakes. And while it might seem like asking Gemini or ChatGPT to cite their sources could prevent errors, the truth is they can still be confidently wrong.
Another risk is advice that seems beneficial in the short term but harmful in the long run. For example, an AI chatbot might give you investment tips that lead to an impressive payoff.
However, if you don’t fully understand taxes or how that investment affects your income bracket, you could potentially owe more money than expected during tax season.
The power of human support
Yes, AI can do a lot of things faster than humans, but it can never replace the value of human support.
No matter how empathetic an AI’s response sounds, it doesn’t truly care about you or your well-being. Reading phrases like “It’s so frustrating living paycheck to paycheck” or “It’s unfair your boss didn’t give you a raise” might feel comforting, but emotions are complex. They can’t be brushed aside with a generic, sympathetic statement.
Only a human can hold space for your emotions and help you explore why you feel triggered. A professional, whether a coach, therapist, or financial advisor, will ask deeper questions, grounded in real human experience and understanding of who you are as a whole. Because you are not just what you type on a screen.
For these reasons and more, certified financial advisors, coaches, mentors, and trusted communities (like Clever Girl Finance) can help you make lasting changes, not just quick fixes.
Can AI create a new budget for you? Absolutely. But can it figure out why you’re not sticking to that budget or recognize the behavioral patterns you keep repeating? No.
Likewise, so much of communication happens non-verbally when humans interact. It might be the tone of voice, a pause between breaths, or the way someone looks away when discussing something uncomfortable. All of these subtle cues communicate meaning AI simply can’t detect. Without that awareness, it’s easy to miss context and receive advice that doesn’t fully fit your situation.
Working with a human allows you to address both the emotional and logical sides of money, paving the way toward true financial wellness and stability.
What you can do instead (or alongside AI)
As we said before, it’s not about choosing one or the other, it’s about using AI alongside other financial strategies.
You can start by using AI for the basics. One way I like to use it is to help simplify concepts I’ve learned. For example, if I’ve read an article about ETFs, I’ll ask AI to give me real-world examples of investing with ETFs so I can better understand how they work.
You can also use AI to create different budget templates, then bring those to a mentor or advisor to decide which one fits your lifestyle best.
Another helpful use is leveraging AI as a search tool to find financial communities or support networks worth joining.
In short, use AI for surface-level questions, and save the personal ones for your financial therapist or coach.
You deserve more than generic advice
Remember, AI doesn’t see you as a person with hopes, dreams, history, and ever-evolving goals. Sure, it may save your chat history, but twenty past conversations don’t capture your whole life or the depth of your lived experiences.
Technology is here to support us, but it can never replace us.
When it comes to your money, you deserve compassion and clarity, not an auto-generated response.
If you want to talk to real people about money, you can join our community, the Clever Girl Finance course community, or our Instagram channel.
💌 Join our main newsletter
Join 50,000+ women who subscribe to our main newsletter (also free!) for day to day money tips, new podcast episodes, recommendations, and access to our tools and courses — all designed to help you take confident action with your finances.
👉 Subscribe here — it's free and packed with value!
📝 Access our 30+ free courses
To build a solid personal finance foundation, check out our 30+ completely free courses and daily updated blog content on clevergirlfinance.com.